Brown Butter Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie
Choose an available window
Available in 2 availability windows. Next up: Thanksgiving Collection | Tuesday, Nov. 24 • Nov 24, 2026.
A little Indiana tradition, straight from our neighborhood bakehouse.
Rich, velvety vanilla bean cream filling, made with browned butter and nestled in our handcrafted brown butter pie crust. Finished with a delicate layer of caramelized cinnamon sugar and beautiful autumn-inspired pastry details.
Sweet, buttery, wonderfully nostalgic, and rooted in Hoosier tradition—this old-fashioned favorite is a little taste of home.
Whole 9-inch pie | Serves 8
Real product photos are coming soon! Follow along as we bake our way through the Thanksgiving Collection.
Select Your Window
Add to Cart
Review details in your cart and choose your payment method at checkout.
We're happy to help with special requests, custom orders, and questions about pickup or delivery.
Looking for something beyond this week's menu?
Get in touch if you're looking for:
- Custom cookie and dessert orders
- Gift boxes for birthdays, new babies, and thoughtful surprises
- Dessert tables for showers and small celebrations
- Questions about pickups, deliveries, or special requests